Movie review by: Michelle
Click here for pictures Jakob the Liar is based on a 1969 novel and
a 1974 German-language film version of it. It is a Holocaust story about a Jew keeping
hope alive in the Warsaw ghetto by inventing good news his neighbors believe he's hearing
on an illegal radio.
Robin Williams takes the title role, a deposed restaurateur eking out a living as slave
labor for the Gestapo along with the frightened remains of a once-lively Jewish village.
The Jews, targeted for disposal by the Third Reich, all live under the assumption that
unless the war ends and they are freed, they will die.
Writer-director Peter Kassovitz (himself a Holocaust survivor) sets this scene in grays
and blacks, with barely enough color left for the yellow stars of David on the front and
back of each Jew's coat. No sun shines, and the sky is only slightly brighter than the
expressions on the people's faces.
It begins when Jakob is sent to German headquarters by a sentry who wrongly accuses him
of being outside after the curfew. The headquarters excuses Jakob and sends him home, but
not before Jakob overhears a snippet of a newscast describing a Russian army attack on
German troops at a nearby village. Elated, he spreads the first news the isolated Jews
have heard in two years. Reluctant to admit that he heard it in German headquarters, he
makes up the lie about the radio, swearing his longtime friend to silence. Before he knows
it, people are smiling at Jakob in the street and tipping their hats to him. And when he
goes off to do forced labor each day in the freight yards, the others in the work gang
press him for more. So he fabricates more and more optimistic news as the false reports
engender real hope. The salutary effect of good news on the ghetto convinces Jakob he
shouldn't deny he has access to a radio. Before long, he's become a local hero, and a
target for Nazi punishment.
Williams does get a chance to show off some of his comic invention, as he imitates
radio broadcasts for a 10-year-old girl who finds refuge in Jakob's attic. But most of
this story simply repeats the horrific messages of the Gestapo oppression of European
Jews. Its appeal will rely on viewer interest in Nazi inhumanity and Jewish survivalism.
It's a well-made film with first-rate performances from the actors. If you appreciate
"Life Is Beautiful", you would appreciate this as well.